December 4, 2007This is a featured page

Meeting notes from Initial Working Group meeting, December 4, 2007


As an outcome of the New York State Resource Sharing Summit June 5-6, 2007, the summit participants identified the need to establish working groups made up of representatives from various library segments and sizes to study the issues of Discovery and Delivery. The charges below were drafted by Nylink based upon the Directors’ Roundtable discussion and revised at the first Delivery Working Group meeting on December 4, 2007.

The Delivery Working Group will advise interested members of the New York library community of the issues and challenges in developing a statewide delivery system that works for different types of libraries and groups, (may be coordinated with existing systems), with a scalable pricing structure. The Delivery Working Group will hold an initial meeting in person, conducts its work via conference calls, and will have a face-to-face meeting in the spring if needed.

The group will provide a report with any recommendations to the library community via a presentation at the October 23-24, 2008 Resource Sharing Summit, and will provide ongoing updates and information to the community via NYLINE postings, a wiki, and other communication means. There are questions that remain due to not all working group members being at the meeting; action items need to be flushed out and volunteers are needed for action items. This will be discussed at the first conference call of the group, to be scheduled in January 2008.

Confirmed Delivery Group Members

• Carol Clemente, Binghamton University • Caleb Derven, New York State Library • Debby Emerson, Rochester Regional Library Council • Sonja Landes, SUNY College at Geneseo • Jeff Katz, Bard College • Jennifer Morris, Pioneer Library System • Francie Mrkich, Columbia University • Eric Neubacher, Baruch College • Zelantha Phillip, Queens Library • Kathleen Gundrum, Nylink • Cindy Hajeck, Nylink

Revised Delivery Group Charges [December 4, 2007]

1. Research the feasibility of and need for a statewide delivery system tool
2. Inventory existing delivery services and existing resource sharing initiatives and examine issues of linking existing services together
3. Provide recommendations for implementation Meeting notes from Initial Working Group meeting, December 4, 2007

Present: Debby Emerson, Rochester Regional Library Council [for portion of meeting via conference call] Jeff Katz, Bard College Francie Mrkich, Columbia University Eric Neubacher, Baruch College Kathleen Gundrum, Nylink Cindy Hajeck, Nylink

Unable to attend: Carol Clemente, Binghamton University Caleb Derven, New York State Library Sonja Landes, SUNY College at Geneseo Jennifer Morris, Pioneer Library System Zelantha Phillip, Queens Library
Notes: Kathy Gundrum

The meeting began with a call for volunteers for various committee roles:
  • Cindy Hajeck will serve as meeting recorder; Cindy and Kathy will work with Nylink staff for organizing and maintaining the Working Groups’ wiki, to be hosted by Nylink. Members of the working group are asked to send information to share, and links to be posted, to Kathy in the interim period until the wiki is established [target date: late January].
  • Kathy Gundrum is willing to serve as co-chair. A volunteer is needed to co-chair this group.
  • Francie Mrkich will work with Deidre Dowling of Nylink on the 2008 Resource Sharing Summit. A second volunteer from the delivery working group is needed to assist in the planning of the summit. The draft charges were reviewed and revisions were made based on discussions. \

Original charges

  • Research the feasibility of and need for a statewide delivery system tool
  • Inventory existing delivery services
  • Examine issues of linking existing services together
  • Provide recommendations for implementing a coordinated system

Discussion and establishment of new charges: There was brief discussion of whether this group should develop its own statement of guiding principles for the work of the group, possibly using the “Rethinking Resource Sharing Manifesto” at http://www.rethinkingresourcesharing.org/manifesto.html as a model.
Action: At January call, determine whether guiding principles for the delivery group are needed and if so, volunteers are needed, with a timeframe established. Regarding the charge: “Research the feasibility of and need for a statewide delivery system tool,” there was discussion of whether there is a need for one statewide delivery service. There may not be one solution for all and we should not limit recommendations to one coordinated service. Start with a statement of the problem: what would a “popular” delivery service be? What do we want to know? How do we establish timely, reliable and affordable delivery services for all libraries in New York? Look at consumer behavior and library users. If we are to do focus groups-focus on the library user [college students, faculty, public library patrons, medical library users, corporate library users] Action items: Determine how we will learn the needs of end users-can focus groups be coordinated at libraries of working group members? Is there a role for public library systems, other systems, here? Who should be targeted? What questions should be asked [a script is needed]? What’s the incentive for focus group participants?

Volunteers:
Timeframe:
Draft a survey, which could be coordinated with the Discovery Working Group. Survey is to be short and targeted, focusing on what the needs are and what libraries are currently using for delivery of physical items.
Volunteers:
Timeframe:
Distribute survey (to be put up in Nylink’s Zoomerang account) on NYLINE and appropriate NYLINE sublists.
Volunteer: Maribeth Krupczak [on Discovery working group]
Timeframe: TBD
The group combined two charges so that a new charge is: “Inventory existing delivery services and existing resource sharing initiatives and examine issues of linking existing services together.” This group will focus on delivery of physical items. There was discussion about delivery of non-returnable items [journal articles] which goes beyond the scope of this group. There was mention of RAPID ILL, and that Nylink should coordinate setting up a RAPID ILL pod for New York. [NOTE: Nylink staff member Jon Penn will explore this possibility at ALA Midwinter].
Action items: Determine approach for looking at existing delivery services [questions to ask, how to track, how to report back, determining questions we want answered]: Inventory systems within New York State [note: survey done prior to 2007 Resource Sharing Summit could be used as a starting point]. Inventory systems beyond New York State Volunteers: Kathy Timeframe: Examine issues of linking existing services together. Can/should those within New York State link together?

Volunteers:
Timeframe:
The action items for providing recommendations for implementation will be discussed at subsequent meetings of the group.



No user avatar
nylink_js
Latest page update: made by nylink_js , Mar 19 2008, 2:28 PM EDT (about this update About This Update nylink_js Edited by nylink_js

1 word added
7 words deleted

view changes

- complete history)
More Info: links to this page

Anonymous  (Get credit for your thread)


There are no threads for this page.  Be the first to start a new thread.

Related Content

  (what's this?Related ContentThanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on Wetpaint Central.)